-
Chengli Automobile Industry Park
Which crane is better, a truck crane or a hydraulic mobile crane?
Truck Crane vs. Hydraulic Mobile Crane: Which Is Better for Your Project?
Are you trying to pick the right crane for your next big job? This is a key choice that can make or break your project’s success. Let’s look at both truck cranes and hydraulic mobile cranes to help you pick the best one.
Table of Contents
What Is a Truck Crane?
A truck crane is a lifting machine that sits on a truck chassis. Think of it as a truck with a crane arm on top. These cranes are good when you need to move around a lot.
Key features of truck cranes:
- Built on a regular truck frame
- Can drive on normal roads easily
- Good for jobs that need lots of moving
- Sets up fast at work sites
- Works well for medium loads
Truck cranes like the XCMG SQ8SK3Q are top picks for many building jobs because they can get to work sites fast and start working right away.
What Is a Hydraulic Mobile Crane?
A hydraulic mobile crane is a strong lifting machine with hydraulic power and a telescoping boom. Unlike truck cranes, these are made just for lifting big, heavy things.
Key features of hydraulic mobile cranes:
- Stronger lifting power (often 18+ tons)
- Telescopic arms that reach high
- More stable for big lifting jobs
- Built for rough ground and hard jobs
- Best for heavy industrial work
The ACE 18XW hydraulic mobile crane shows what these machines can do, with its 18-ton lifting power and reach of nearly 18 meters.
Key Differences Between the Two Cranes
Mobility & Setup Time
- Truck cranes: Drive like normal trucks and set up in minutes
- Hydraulic mobile cranes: Need more time to set up but work better on rough ground
Lifting Power
| Type | Typical Capacity | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Truck Crane | 15-50 tons | Construction, urban projects |
| Hydraulic Mobile Crane | Up to 200+ tons | Industrial, heavy infrastructure |
The market for hydraulic truck cranes is growing fast, with a CAGR of 5.5% from 2025 to 2032 and expected to hit $19.07 billion by 2032.
Truck Crane vs. Hydraulic Mobile Crane
Key Features
Truck Crane: Mounted on a truck, good for transport.
Hydraulic Mobile Crane: Standalone, great for heavy lifting.
Market Growth (CAGR) Comparison
Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) indicates the yearly growth rate of an investment over a specified period, assuming profits are reinvested during the term.
Typical Lifting Capacity (Tons)
Lifting capacity refers to the maximum weight a crane can safely lift. It’s crucial for matching the right crane to your project’s needs.
Common Use Cases
Truck Crane: Urban construction, equipment repair, quick material transport.
Hydraulic Mobile Crane: Industrial plants, oil & gas projects, large-scale infrastructure.
Key Manufacturers
Truck Cranes: Liebherr, XCMG, Sany Heavy Industry
Hydraulic Cranes: Konecranes, Terex, Tadano
Where They Work Best
- Truck cranes shine in city jobs and places with good roads
- Hydraulic mobile cranes handle rough ground and tight spots better
Cost & Value
- Truck cranes: Less money up front, good for smaller jobs
- Hydraulic mobile cranes: Cost more but lift more, best for big projects
Which Crane Should You Choose?
Pick a Truck Crane If:
- You need to move between job sites often
- Your loads are under 50 tons
- You work mostly on flat, solid ground
- You need to get set up fast
- You have a tight budget
Truck cranes are great for urban construction projects where you need to move around the city and set up quickly.
Pick a Hydraulic Mobile Crane If:
- You need to lift very heavy things (over 50 tons)
- Your job site has rough or uneven ground
- You need to reach high places
- Your project is big and will last a long time
- Safety with heavy loads is your top concern
The mobile crane market is growing at 6.2-6.4% yearly, expected to reach $17.65 billion by 2025. This growth shows how much these cranes help in big building projects.
Real-World Success Stories
Truck Crane Win: A city building job used an XCMG SQ8SK3Q truck-mounted crane to lift steel beams in a tight space. The crane could drive right up to the spot, lift what was needed, and move to the next area fast.
Hydraulic Mobile Crane Win: A big power plant job used the ACE 18XW hydraulic crane to place heavy parts that weighed over 15 tons each. The crane’s strong lifting power and good reach made the job safe and fast.
Key Market Trends
The crane industry is changing fast with new tech and needs:
- Electric drive options are growing for truck cranes
- AI controls are making hydraulic cranes safer and more exact
- Both types are getting more eco-friendly systems
- The mobile crane market will be worth over $15 billion by the end of 2024
For specialized projects, the mobile crane truck market offers solutions that combine the best features of both crane types.
Comparison Table: Truck Crane vs. Hydraulic Mobile Crane
| Category | Truck Crane | Hydraulic Mobile Crane | Key Insights |
|---|---|---|---|
| Market Growth | CAGR of 5.5% (2025-2032) | CAGR of 6.2-6.4% (2025-2030) | Hydraulic models growing faster for heavy industry |
| Key Makers | Liebherr, XCMG, Sany | Konecranes, Terex, Tadano | Both have global giants making them |
| Lifting Power | 15-50 tons typical | Up to 200+ tons | Hydraulic cranes lift much more |
| Common Uses | Urban building, quick lifts, equipment repair | Big plants, oil & gas, large buildings | Truck cranes for speed, hydraulic for power |
| Growth Drivers | City building, cost savings | Green energy, oil & gas growth | Both help with more city building |
| New Trends | Electric power options, custom bodies | AI controls, hybrid power | Both getting greener and smarter |
FAQ About Cranes
Can a truck crane lift as much as a hydraulic mobile crane?
No, truck cranes usually lift less (15-50 tons) while hydraulic mobile cranes can lift 200+ tons.
Which sets up faster?
Truck cranes win here – they can drive in and start working much faster than hydraulic cranes.
Which is safer for very heavy loads?
Hydraulic mobile cranes are built just for heavy lifting, with better stability systems for the biggest loads.
Do I need special roads for these cranes?
Truck cranes can use normal roads, but the biggest hydraulic mobile cranes might need special permits.
Conclusion
There’s no one “best” crane – it all depends on your job:
- For city work, quick moves, and medium loads: Choose a truck-mounted crane.
- For the heaviest lifts, tough ground, and big projects: Pick a hydraulic mobile crane.
The best choice comes down to what you need to lift, where you need to lift it, and how often you’ll move the crane.
Think about your budget, but also think about how the right crane can save you time and money in the long run. Experts from top companies like Liebherr or Terex can help you pick the perfect crane for your needs.
